PO.PR02.02 · 预防研究
突破可规模化多癌种早期检测(MCED)的障碍
Breaking barriers to scalable multi-cancer early detection (MCED)
作者与单位 Authors & Affiliations
摘要 Abstract
中文摘要
近年来,通过液体活检进行的MCED因其有可能将癌症检测的范式从单一转向多种、从晚期转向早期而备受关注。然而,实现这一前景需要应对若干根本性挑战,否则MCED有可能仍局限于昂贵的小众市场,而无法成为广泛实用的临床工具。这些挑战包括技术、方法学、心理和经济等因素。虽然在所有早期阶段进行检测都具有挑战性,但检测处于I期的实体癌相比II期要困难得多。对于四种最常见的实体癌,体积测量表明,I期的检测难度大约是II期的5到30倍。这种非线性挑战,加上某些癌症类型的固有性质,凸显了真正的早期检测方案对灵敏度的苛刻要求,以及许多先进分子平台所面临的局限性。特异性构成了一个并行的挑战。在保持较强I期灵敏度的同时维持高特异性本质上是困难的,因为早期癌症信号可能与健康基线非常相似。例如,I期灵敏度的妥协可能表现为特异性表面上的提高。反过来,如果解读时不加谨慎,这可能导致对阳性预测值(PPV)的感知性夸大。严谨的队列设计对于防止准确性失真至关重要。仔细考量年龄、合并症及相关变量对于避免重大后果至关重要。例如,偏向老年人的队列可能会虚高感知到的PPV。同样,癌症组和健康组之间的年龄差异可能会误导指标,因为老年个体的非癌症信号可能会虚高表面上的灵敏度。心理因素可能会阻碍癌症筛查,在同时针对多种癌症的MCED中,恐惧和焦虑尤为突出。将MCED用作分诊而非确定性筛查检测可以减轻这些顾虑,因为阳性结果会促使进行确诊性筛查。然而,虽然这种方法使MCED成为一个易于获取的入口,但它将要求高灵敏度,尤其是在最早期的癌症阶段。最后,成本仍是一个关键考量。要使MCED获得广泛采用,它必须在经济上可行,确保成本效益、可及的报销途径,进而在人群层面实现可负担性。这些经济因素将是其现实可行性的关键。在这项工作中,我们提出了一种低成本、高灵敏度/特异性的MCED,利用蛋白质组学和机器智能,最初针对乳腺癌、肺癌、前列腺癌和结肠癌。通过应对这些关键挑战,我们展示了MCED如何能够从昂贵的小众市场演变为可用于大规模癌症早期检测的、具有临床可操作性的工具。
查看英文原文 English abstract
In recent years, MCED via liquid biopsy has risen to prominence for its potential to shift the paradigm of cancer detection from one to many, and from late to early stages. Yet, realizing this promise requires addressing several fundamental challenges, without which MCED risks remaining confined to expensive niche markets rather than becoming a broadly practical clinical tool. These challenges comprise technical, methodological, psychological, and economic factors. While detection at all early stages is challenging, detecting solid cancers at Stage I is significantly more demanding compared to Stage II. For the four most common solid cancers, volumetric measurements suggest that Stage I is roughly 5 to 30 times harder to detect than Stage II. This nonlinear challenge, compounded by the inherent nature of some cancer types, highlights the demanding sensitivity requirements of a true early detection scheme and the limitations faced by many advanced molecular platforms. Specificity poses a parallel challenge. Maintaining high specificity while simultaneously preserving strong Stage I sensitivity is intrinsically difficult because early cancer signals can closely resemble healthy baselines. A compromise in Stage I sensitivity, for instance, could translate to apparent increased specificity. This, in turn, could lead to a perceived exaggeration of the positive predictive value (PPV) if not interpreted with caution. Rigorous cohort design is essential to prevent distortion of accuracy. Careful consideration of age, comorbidities, and related variables is crucial to avoid significant consequences. For example, an older-skewed cohort could falsely inflate the perceived PPV. Similarly, age differences between cancer and healthy groups can mislead metrics, as older individuals' non-cancer signals may falsely raise apparent sensitivity. Psychological factors can hinder cancer screening, with fear and anxiety particularly high in MCED, which targets multiple cancers simultaneously. Employing MCED as a triage rather than a definitive screening test can reduce these concerns, as positive results prompt confirmatory screening. However, while this approach makes MCED an accessible entry point, it would demand high sensitivity, particularly at the earliest cancer stages. Lastly, cost remains a critical consideration. For MCED to achieve widespread adoption, it must be economically viable, ensuring cost-effectiveness, accessible reimbursement pathways, and consequently affordability at the population level. These economic factors will be key to its real-world feasibility. In this work, we present a low-cost, high-sensitivity/specificity MCED leveraging proteomics and machine intelligence, initially targeting breast, lung, prostate, and colon cancers. By addressing the key challenges, we demonstrate how MCED can evolve from a costly niche market to a clinically actionable tool for large-scale early cancer detection.
利益披露 Disclosure
B. G. Kermani,
Crystal Genetics, Inc. Employment, Stock, Patent, Trademark, Other Intellectual Property, Other, Executive Role.
Guardant Health, Inc. Stock, Patent.
Illumina, Inc. Stock, Patent.
Complete Genomics, Inc. Patent.